Failed Justifications: Why Privacy and Federalism Do Not Support the Ban on a Federal Unit-Record System

Failed Justifications: Why Privacy and Federalism Do Not Support the Ban on a Federal Unit-Record System
This article suggests that the ban on a federal unit-record system cannot be supported by appeals to either privacy or federalism. Because these arguments were not fully developed by the opponents of the unit-record system and were not even explicit in the case of federalism concerns it is useful to consider legal and normative arguments within each category to determine whether either privacy or federalism can lend policy support to the legislative decision to ban a unit-record system. Ultimately, all of these arguments fall short. Part I discusses the character and relative advantages of a federal unit-record system. Part II briefly looks at the debate leading up to the 2008 reauthorization. Part III turns to the question of privacy, addressing constitutional, statutory, and normative arguments and dismissing each as insufficient to justify the statutory ban. Part IV anticipates the likely rejoinder based in legal
and normative arguments concerning federalism and again dismisses each as insufficient to justify the ban. By debunking arguments based on privacy and federalism, this Note will show that opponents of a federal unit-record system cannot maintain their opposition based on these principles alone, if and when the question of establishing the database is raised again.  Login required.

Related Resources

  • News Article

    Model: Student Data Privacy School Board Policy, Carroll County Public Schools

    Aug 1, 2019

    Carroll County Public Schools revised its student data governance policy to be “comprehensive” and to serve as a framework that can be built on in the future.T…

    Learn More
  • News Article

    Our 2019 EdTech Security Survey

    Jun 19, 2019

    Common Sense released this 2019 EdTech Security Survey as part of a semi-annual examination of security practices of education technology-related online servic…

    Learn More
  • News Article

    IF can help you understand what’s happening with data you hold

    Apr 19, 2019Sarah Gold

    This article describes a data management and protection tool called IF.

    Learn More